How Culture Influences Educational Practices | Focus on Reading Comprehension

Mastering Academic Texts: How Culture Shapes Education

Hello and welcome to your reading practice session! Today we’re diving into a topic from the fields of sociology and education. Academic passages like this one are common on tests like the TOEFL and IELTS. They often use a compare-and-contrast structure to explore complex ideas. Your job is to identify the different viewpoints or models being presented and understand the key characteristics of each.

To excel on this type of passage, focus on these skills:

• Identify the Core Contrast: Look for the two main concepts being compared. In this passage, it’s “individualistic” versus “collectivist” cultures. Every point will relate back to this core contrast.
• Look for Signal Words: Pay attention to words that signal comparison or contrast, such as “similarly,” “in contrast,” “while,” “whereas,” and “on the other hand.” They are signposts that guide you through the argument.
• Understand Cause and Effect: The passage will argue that a certain cultural value causes a certain educational practice. Your goal is to understand these connections.
• Pace Yourself: In a real exam, you won’t have unlimited time. Practice makes perfect. Try to complete this reading and the 10 questions in 15 to 18 minutes.

Let’s begin.

Reading Passage

Education does not occur in a vacuum. It is a deeply embedded cultural practice that reflects and perpetuates the values of the society it serves. The methods of teaching, the nature of student-teacher relationships, and even the architectural design of classrooms are all shaped by a society’s underlying cultural orientation. One of the most well-researched frameworks for understanding this connection is the distinction between individualistic and collectivist cultures. This socio-cultural lens provides profound insight into why educational practices can differ so dramatically across the globe.

In predominantly individualistic cultures, such as those in the United States and Western Europe, the primary emphasis is on personal achievement, independence, and self-reliance. The educational system in these societies is often structured to foster these values. Classroom activities are designed to encourage critical thinking, creativity, and the expression of unique, personal opinions. Students are expected to question information, engage in debate with the teacher and their peers, and work autonomously on projects. The role of the teacher is often that of a facilitator, guiding students to discover knowledge for themselves. Assessment methods, in turn, frequently value individual contribution, with an emphasis on essays, personal projects, and other tasks that showcase originality.

In stark contrast, collectivist cultures, common in many parts of Asia, Africa, and Latin America, prioritize group harmony, interdependence, and respect for authority. The educational philosophy in these contexts is geared towards reinforcing the individual’s role as a member of a community. The pedagogical approach tends to be more teacher-centered and hierarchical. Teachers are viewed as revered experts whose role is to transmit a body of established knowledge to the students, who are expected to listen and absorb it diligently. Rote memorization and the ability to reproduce information accurately are often highly valued skills, seen as the foundation upon which higher learning is built. Classroom activities emphasize collaborative work and consensus-building, and it may be considered disrespectful for a student to openly challenge the teacher’s authority.

These differing cultural paradigms also influence the very purpose of education. In individualistic societies, education is often seen as a tool for personal empowerment and upward social mobility—a means for the individual to improve their own standing in life. In collectivist societies, however, education is frequently viewed as a means to become a productive and responsible member of the community, family, and nation. The success of a student is not just a personal victory but a source of honor for their entire family and social group.

It is crucial to recognize that these are broad generalizations and that neither system is inherently superior. Each is effective at cultivating the skills and values necessary to function within its specific socio-cultural context. However, as globalization increases intercultural contact, these differing educational philosophies can become a source of misunderstanding. A student from a collectivist culture might appear passive or unengaged in an individualistic classroom, while a student from an individualistic background might be perceived as disruptive or disrespectful in a collectivist setting. Understanding the deep-rooted cultural assumptions that underpin educational practices is therefore essential for fostering effective and equitable global education in the 21st century.

Reading Quiz

Advanced Vocabulary and Phrases

1. Perpetuate: A verb meaning to make something (typically a situation, belief, or value) continue indefinitely.
   • How we used it: Education is said to perpetuate a society’s values, meaning it helps to keep them going from one generation to the next.
2. Individualistic: An adjective describing a society that prioritizes individual freedom, achievement, and self-reliance.
   • How we used it: We described cultures like the U.S. as individualistic, which explains their focus on personal opinion and creativity in schools.
3. Collectivist: An adjective describing a society that prioritizes the group over the individual, emphasizing harmony, interdependence, and community.
   • How we used it: We described cultures in parts of Asia as collectivist, which explains their focus on group work and respect for authority in schools.
4. Autonomously: An adverb meaning with the freedom to act independently.
   • How we used it: In individualistic classrooms, students are often expected to work autonomously on their own projects.
5. Pedagogical: An adjective relating to the theory and practice of teaching.
   • How we used it: The pedagogical approach in collectivist cultures is described as more teacher-centered.
6. Hierarchical: An adjective describing a system in which members of an organization or society are ranked according to relative status or authority.
   • How we used it: The relationship between teacher and student in a collectivist setting is often more hierarchical.
7. Rote memorization: A noun phrase for a learning technique based on repetition. The idea is that one will be able to quickly recall the meaning of the material the more one repeats it.
   • How we used it: Rote memorization is described as a highly valued skill in some educational systems, as it forms a base of knowledge.
8. Inherently: An adverb meaning in a permanent, essential, or characteristic way.
   • How we used it: The author states that neither educational system is inherently superior, meaning that there is nothing in their basic nature that makes one better than the other.
9. Underpin: A verb meaning to support, justify, or form the basis for an argument, claim, or theory.
   • How we used it: Understanding the cultural assumptions that underpin educational practices means understanding the core beliefs that form the foundation of those practices.
10. Equitable: An adjective meaning fair and impartial.
    • How we used it: The author’s goal is to foster equitable global education, meaning an educational environment that is fair to students from all cultural backgrounds.

Unlock A World of Learning by Becoming a Patron