Who is it, exactly, that gets told not to make waves?
Sit with that before we go anywhere else, because the answer is the most revealing thing about the phrase. It’s almost never said to the person in charge. It’s said to the new one. The junior one. The one who noticed something wrong and hasn’t yet learned that noticing is optional.
Don’t make waves. It arrives disguised as career advice, and it functions as an instruction about who is permitted to disturb a surface.
But before the politics, the physics — because the physics is startling, and it changes the whole metaphor.
Here’s the thing about a wave: the water doesn’t travel.
That’s the counterintuitive fact at the heart of it. When a wave crosses an ocean, the water is not crossing the ocean. Each parcel of water moves in a small circle — up, forward a little, down, back — and ends up more or less where it started. What travels is not the substance. What travels is the energy, and the shape that energy makes as it passes through.
Watch a bird sitting on the sea. A wave goes by, the bird rises and falls, and afterward it’s in almost exactly the same place. The wave has moved on. The bird has not gone with it.
So a wave is a pattern of energy moving through a medium that mostly stays put.
And that changes what making waves means entirely.
Because the objection is usually framed as: you’ll displace everything, you’ll upend the whole system, you’ll move things that don’t want to be moved. And that’s not what a wave does. A wave doesn’t relocate the ocean. It passes through it. Each part of the medium moves a little, in place, and hands the energy on.
Which is a rather good description of how change actually spreads through a group of people.
You say the thing in the meeting. You don’t move the institution — you couldn’t, you’re one person and it’s enormous. What you do is put energy into the medium. And the person next to you moves a little. And they say something in a corridor to someone who moves a little. Nobody is displaced. Everyone keeps their job. And the energy travels much further than you ever will.
That’s the honest scale of it, and I think it’s more encouraging than the heroic version. You are not required to move the ocean. You’re required to disturb your own patch of it hard enough that the energy has somewhere to go.
Now — two more pieces of wave behavior, and both matter.
The first: a wave grows as it approaches the shallows.
Out in deep water a large swell can pass beneath you almost unnoticed — a slow rise, a slow fall. It’s only when the seabed climbs toward the shore that the wave steepens, and stands up, and breaks. All of its visible drama happens at the edges, far from wherever it began.
So the effect of a disturbance is usually greatest at the margins. The thing you said in a comfortable room may pass nearly unnoticed there and arrive somewhere shallower with real force — reaching the person who had no power in that room, who needed someone to say it, who will remember it for years. You will almost certainly never see that shore.
The second piece: a flat surface is not evidence of health.
This is the assumption buried in the whole phrase, and it’s worth digging out. Don’t make waves treats stillness as the natural, correct, desirable state — as though calm water were the definition of a system working.
But a dead pond is perfectly flat. Stagnant water is the flattest water there is. Meanwhile the healthiest water on earth — the reefs, the estuaries, the cold northern seas thick with life — is never still for a moment. Movement is how water breathes. Waves are literally part of the mechanism by which oxygen enters the sea.
So the smooth surface everybody is protecting is not necessarily peace. Sometimes it is. And sometimes it’s the specific stillness of a place where nobody has said anything true in a long time, and everyone has agreed the calm is worth more than the oxygen.
Which gives you a test, and it’s the useful part.
Ask what the flatness is made of. If a surface is calm because things are genuinely well — because problems get raised, dealt with, and the water settles again — then that’s a living calm, and disturbing it for the sake of disturbance is just vandalism. There are people who make waves as a personality, and they aren’t oxygenating anything; they’re enjoying the splash.
But if the flatness is maintained — if it requires everyone to not say the obvious thing, if it costs continuous effort, if you can feel the pressure of everything unsaid holding the surface down — then that isn’t calm. That’s a lid. And the correct response to a lid is a wave.
So the phrase turns out to be doing something quite specific. It asks you to value the appearance of a system over its condition. And the reason it’s usually aimed at the person with least power is that they have the least to lose from the truth, and are therefore the likeliest source of a disturbance.
So here’s what I’ll leave you with tonight.
Think of a surface in your life that’s very flat — a workplace, a family table, a group of old friends. And ask whether that flatness is resting or being held. Whether it settled on its own, or whether it takes everyone in the room a small continuous effort to keep it that way.
And if it’s being held, remember the physics: the water won’t have to go anywhere. That’s the whole point. Everyone stays in place; only the energy moves.
So what’s the wave you haven’t made? And who is standing on a shallower shore than yours, waiting for it to arrive?
0 Comments